The American document entitled the “zero draft,” dated 20 October 2026, constitutes an initial working document intended to serve as the starting point for discussions among Security Council members on the renewal of MINURSO’s mandate.
However, given its deeply biased and questionable nature, this draft, which adopts all of Morocco’s demands, should be subject to numerous substantive amendments.
Its current wording reflects a clear bias in favour of the Moroccan position and departs from the balance required for a settlement consistent with the principles of the United Nations.
The imbalance is evident, first and foremost, in the way the text presents Morocco’s autonomy proposal. This proposal is repeatedly elevated to the status of the exclusive basis for negotiations, while the draft asserts that autonomy under Moroccan sovereignty constitutes the only solution to the conflict. Such wording prejudges the outcome of the political process before the parties have even reached an agreement. It considerably narrows the scope for negotiations and confronts the other stakeholders with an option presented as both exclusive and unavoidable.
The reference to self-determination in the preamble is insufficient to rectify this contradiction. The principle is mentioned, but the operative provisions of the draft substantially restrict its scope.
The proposed wording also raises a major concern regarding the balance between the parties. The text explicitly deplores one party’s refusal to participate meaningfully in the negotiations, while exclusively reproducing the political arguments favourable to Rabat.
It also condemns the attack on Smara on 5 May 2026, but offers no comparable assessment of Morocco’s responsibility for the persistence of the conflict, particularly with regard to the use of drones, including against civilians.
This asymmetrical treatment of the parties risks undermining the credibility of the Security Council as the guarantor of an impartial negotiating process.
Several members should therefore seek to restore a more balanced text.
The draft seeks to undermine the Polisario Front’s status as the sole representative of the Sahrawi people and calls for consultations with “Sahrawi components” outside the Polisario Front, the conclusions of which would be incorporated into the Secretary-General’s reports.
The section dealing with MINURSO’s future constitutes another major point of contention. The draft provides for MINURSO to be renamed the “United Nations Mission for Western Sahara” (MINUSO), thereby eliminating the “R” for referendum, which has haunted the Moroccan monarchy for decades. This change calls into question the parameters that underpinned the Mission’s establishment and fundamentally distorts the very nature of the conflict, which is a decolonization issue whose settlement must guarantee the exercise of the right to self-determination.
The draft also provides for the termination of the Mission’s peacekeeping mandate on 30 April 2027, followed by its transformation into a special political mission for a period of six months. It also calls for a reduction of at least 50% in uniformed personnel as early as 31 January 2027.
These provisions therefore entail a profound reorientation of the UN presence in Western Sahara, even though the dispute remains unresolved.
Council members will therefore have to examine the practical consequences of this timetable, the tasks that would be discontinued and the safeguards needed to prevent the gradual withdrawal of peacekeeping resources from creating a dangerous vacuum that would seriously undermine regional stability.
Finally, the draft introduces the issue of registering the refugee population in the Tindouf area. This could become another highly sensitive issue if it were instrumentalised for political purposes.
In its current form, this zero draft appears less like a balanced basis for negotiations than an attempt to impose a predetermined political framework.
For this reason, discussions in the Security Council will now have to focus on both the substance and the very architecture of the draft resolution, particularly the exclusivity granted to the Moroccan plan, the reference to self-determination, the impartiality of the political process and the arrangements for restructuring MINURSO.
Amar Belani
#USA #WesternSahara #DraftResolution #Morocco #SecurityCouncil

Soyez le premier à commenter