Former Algerian diplomat Amar Belani warns that Spain cannot transfer management of Western Sahara’s airspace to Morocco without raising serious questions under international law. The dispute touches on the territory’s unresolved status, Spain’s responsibilities as former administering power, and the Sahrawi people’s right to self-determination. Spain’s opposition People’s Party is calling for continued Spanish control and parliamentary debate before any decision.
Former Algerian diplomat Amar Belani believes that Spain cannot transfer management of Western Sahara’s airspace to Morocco without raising serious questions of international law. At the heart of this controversy: the still-unfinished status of the territory, Madrid’s responsibilities, and the Sahrawi people’s right to self-determination.
Morocco is reportedly stepping up pressure on Spain to obtain the transfer of control of Western Sahara’s airspace, currently managed by Madrid. A possible decision to that effect could open a new diplomatic front around this disputed territory, whose decolonization process remains unfinished. In a commentary devoted to this question, former Algerian diplomat Amar Belani warns against the legal and political consequences of such a transfer.
For Amar Belani, the issue goes far beyond the technical management of air traffic. It directly concerns the international status of Western Sahara and the responsibilities incumbent on Spain as the former administering power of the territory.
A territory still on the decolonization agenda
Western Sahara still appears on the United Nations list of non-self-governing territories. Its final status has not been settled, and the Sahrawi people’s right to self-determination remains at the heart of the decolonization process.
In this context, Amar Belani challenges any step likely to strengthen Morocco’s position in the territory without a prior political settlement. He recalls that Morocco does not appear on the United Nations list as the administering power of Western Sahara.
According to the former diplomat, Spain therefore cannot unilaterally shirk its responsibilities by transferring to Rabat the management of an airspace associated with a territory whose status remains pending.
This position raises a fundamental question: can a decision presented as an administrative or technical measure have repercussions on a still-open decolonization file?
The Madrid Agreement at the heart of the legal debate
To support his argument, Amar Belani refers to the legal opinion issued in 2002 by Hans Corell, then United Nations legal counsel, concerning activities for the exploration of Western Sahara’s natural resources.
This opinion recalls in particular that the 1975 Madrid Agreement did not transfer sovereignty over the territory and did not confer on Morocco the status of administering power within the meaning of international law.
The former diplomat relies on this interpretation to emphasize that the political arrangements concluded between Madrid, Rabat and Nouakchott in 1975 cannot, by themselves, settle the international status of Western Sahara.
Consequently, a transfer of airspace management to Morocco would, according to him, risk strengthening Rabat’s de facto position without resolving the fundamental question of decolonization.
However, the operational management of an airspace should be distinguished from the legal recognition of sovereignty. A technical delegation does not automatically constitute recognition of sovereignty, but its modalities and political context could raise questions about its implications.
The Spanish People’s Party calls for maintaining Spanish control
The controversy also takes on a political dimension in Spain. The People’s Party (PP), the main conservative opposition party, is asking Pedro Sánchez’s government to keep the management of Western Sahara’s airspace under Spanish control.
According to the points put forward by Amar Belani, the PP also calls for the requirements of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) to be respected, for the institutions of the Canary Islands to be informed of negotiations with Rabat, and for a parliamentary debate to take place before any decision.
The party also wants the competent international bodies to be involved in the matter.
This position highlights the concerns raised by a possible modification of the current arrangements. For opponents of a transfer, the issue cannot be treated as a simple matter of bilateral aeronautical cooperation, given its possible repercussions on the status of the territory.
Air navigation safety must indeed be ensured in accordance with international standards. But these technical imperatives do not, by themselves, settle questions of sovereignty, territorial administration or self-determination.
Madrid faces its historical responsibilities
Beyond legal considerations, Amar Belani places Spain before what he considers a particular political and moral responsibility. As the former administering power of Western Sahara, Madrid should, according to him, avoid any decision likely to prejudge the final status of the territory before a solution consistent with international law is found.
The issue is also diplomatic. A transfer of competencies to Morocco could be interpreted as consolidating its effective control over part of the territory, even if such a decision would not necessarily constitute, legally, recognition of sovereignty.
For the former Algerian diplomat, Spain must therefore separate any cooperation in air navigation from the political settlement of the conflict.
Ultimately, he calls on Madrid not to grant Rabat a political advantage likely to weaken the Sahrawi people’s position in their claim to self-determination.
Behind the battle for control of the airspace thus looms a central question: how far can Spain go in its cooperation with Morocco without risking further blurring the legal contours of a still-unfinished decolonization process?
#airspace #Western_Sahara #Morocco #Spain #AmarBelani #Western_Sahara_airspace #Airspace #InternationalLaw #Decolonization #Sahrawi #MadridAgreement #ICAO #UN

Soyez le premier à commenter